![]() |
The town seal of Beverly, Massachusetts |
I share this ancestor, Thomas Tuck (1611 - 1667) with my fellow genealogy blogger, Bill West, who unfortunately passed away last year. Bill wrote three interesting blog posts about Thomas Tuck, and you can find the links below at the end of this post. It was Bill who called our common ancestor "Troublesome Thomas Tuck".
Thomas Tuck was my 9th great grandfather, born about 1611 probably in England. He died in Beverly, Massachusetts on 20 March 1667. Years after he died his ghost became part of the 1692 witch trails, when someone accused him of coming back from the dead to urge her to buy some land! In my opinion his ghost was mentioned because he was not particularly law abiding during his life. But we will never know, will we?
" And for seeing the devill, or any spirit but ones, & that was soon after old Thomas Tuck dyed (w'ch I take to be about ten yeare since) & that shee took it to be the Ghost of Thom: tuck coming to speak w'th her about some land s'd Tuck had told her of before his death. But that shee fled from the Ghost & got away." Salem Witch Papers No. 68.18 Examination of Dorcas Hoar 2 May 1692
I'm on a search to learn more about Thomas Tuck's wife. Or his wives. I wasn't sure how many times he married, or which wife might have been the mother of my 8th great grandfather, John Tuck, born in 1646 in Beverly and died there in 1722. There is no mention of Thomas Tuck, unfortunately, in any of the Great Migration Books, so I can assume he came to Massachusetts after 1635 (which is the drop off date for Robert Charles Anderson's research). He is not found in many other records except for court records, where I can find many, many mentions of his misadventures.
In Sidney Perley's History of Salem, 1924, Volume 1, pages 399 - 401 there is a very short mention of Thomas Tuck. No, not three pages on him, just three sentences in the footnotes:
"Thomas Tuck, a blacksmith, aged about twenty-five, lived on Cape Ann side in 1636. In 1643 he was living apart from his wife, and in 1650 he had married the widow of George Harris. His wife was Joan in 1679. In 1643 he was complained of for living absent from his wife, but was discharged."
What facts do I learn from this tiny paragraph? Or what new questions do I have? How many wives did Thomas Tuck have? Which wife was my ancestress? Where can I find more records? Does he appear anywhere except in court records? Why was he a part of the Salem Witch Hysteria?
Fortunately, after a lot of digging over many months, I found a terrific resource. Someone had done a sketch of Thomas Tuck and his children in the 2018 edition of the New England Historic Genealogical Society Register journal, hidden inside an article about George Harris (Yes! The same George Harris mentioned in that brief little paragraph in the History of Salem.) And this article answered all my questions about Troublesome Thomas Tuck, and even brought up some new questions and further things to investigate.
My question was how many wives did Thomas Tuck have? Apparently he had two, one before "Joan". Joan's previous marriage to George Harris left her with three sons. One of these sons, Samuel Harris (1644-1682) was married to Mary Hoar, the daughter of accused witch Dorcas (Galley) Hoar. This news explained a lot of the mentions in court records of Thomas Tuck being the "father-in-law" (step-father) to Joseph Harris. It also explains why the Tuck and Harris children were called to testify at Dorcas Hoar's trial for witchcraft in 1692.
The article also listed many, many resources in the footnotes for additional deeds, court records, and other information. Some of the best I found were compiled genealogies done on the Harris family, which helped me to sort out the Tuck family!
Thomas and Joan Tuck had only one known child, my 8th great grandfather John Tuck (1646 - 1722) who married a Rachel (________) - another brick wall female line to untangle. But they had six children including my 7th great grandfather John Tuck (1674 - 1717), and his sister Mary Tuck (1682 - 1741/2) who married John Balch the grandson of my 8th great grandparents Benjamin Balch and Sarah Gardner. Another daughter-in-law, Sarah Reith, remarried, when her husband Joseph Tuck died, to Samuel Allen of Manchester, Massachusetts (My mother's maiden name is Allen, a descendant of William Allen (1602 - 1678) of Manchester, so I need to find the kinship connection for this Samuel Allen). I had some notes on these Balch/Tuck/Reith/Allen families already in my files. I'm sure that I can unravel it all now with this new information.
Don't forget to check journal articles, blog posts, and compiled genealogies of related families when you hit a Brick Wall ancestor! Especially new articles published in the last five years, which may not be mentioned as much as articles from the 20th century or early 2000s (or show up on online searches).
For the truly curious:
History of Salem, by Sidney Perley, 1924, Volume 1, pages 399 - 401.
NEHGS Register, 2018, Volume 172, pages 302 - 304 George Harris 1 of Salem, Massachusetts, with Sketch of Thomas 1 Tuck, by Gale Ion Harris https://www.americanancestors.org/DB202/i/55221/304/73267555
The Salem Witchcraft Papers, at salemlib.virginia.edu/texts/transcripts.html, SWP No. 68.4 (deposition of Rachel Tuck and Hannah Cox v. Dorcas Hoar, 14 May 1692)
To cite/link to this blog post: Heather Wilkinson Rojo, "Troublesome Thomas Tuck of Beverly, Massachusetts", Nutfield Genealogy, posted April 22, 2025, ( https://nutfieldgenealogy.blogspot.com/2025/04/troublesome-thomas-tuck-of-beverly.html: accessed [access date]).