Monday, October 29, 2012

A Halloween Ancestor Story! The Gloucester Sea Monster

The first account of a sea monster off the coast of Gloucester, Massachusetts was given by John Josselyn in 1638.   In the summer of 1817 there were many citizens of Gloucester  who reported seeing a sea serpent or monster.  These eyewitness reports  were from men, women, landlubbers and seasoned sailors. Over the years, the reports continued, and the last big sighting was in 1918. 

George Washington’s former staff member, General David Humphreys, interviewed several witnesses, and their testimony is fascinating. A three member panel in Boston took testimonies from doctors, businessmen, clergymen and soldiers.  Two nuns and several fishermen saw it just north of Gloucester.  There were over twenty sightings in 1817. You can read accounts in the Salem Gazette, the Boston Daily Advertiser and the Philadelphia Magazine.  If you have Cape Ann ancestors, you might want to see if they are in some of the interviews!

The testimony of Shipmaster Solomon Allen III, from 12 August 1817:  “… a strange marine animal, that believe to be a serpent, at the southward and eastward end of Ten Pound Island, in the harbor of Gloucester….His head formed something like the head of a rattlesnake, but nearly as large as the head of a horse.  When he moved on the surface of the water his motion was slow, at times playing in circles, and sometimes moving straight forward”

The problem is that I can count nine Solomon Allens in my family tree, all living in Gloucester, Massachusetts.  Even by subtracting the ones who weren't living in 1817, I still have a half dozen possibilities for the Solomon Allen in the history books who witnessed the sea monster.  (and all of the possibilities are relatives, oh my!)

1. Solomon Allen, son of John Allen and Eunice Stone, born 6 December 1737 in Gloucester and died 6 June 1836 in Gloucester; married on 6 June 1754 in Gloucester to Susanna Riggs, daughter of Joshua Riggs. He is a first cousin, 7 generations removed, grandson of my 7th great grandfather John Stone (1661 - 1736), and also the great grandson of my 10th great grandfather, William Allen (1611 - 1686), our immigrant ancestor from Yarmouth, England. 

    2.  Solomon Allen, son of David Allen and Hannah Paddleford, born 23 Mar 1744- no death or marriage information.

3.  Solomon Allen, son of Solomon Allen and Susanna Riggs, born 8 April 1755 in Gloucester; married first on 13 October 1780  to Mary Haskell; married  second on 27 November 1796 to Esther Wallace; married third on 20 May 1800 to Abigail Flowers.  He is a 2nd cousin, 6 generations removed. 

     4. Solomon Allen, son of William Allen and Mary Ingalls, born 14 December 1755 in the Chebacco Parish of Ipswich (now Essex, the town next to Gloucester). He is my 6th great uncle, brother to Isaac Allen (b. 1740), my 6th great grandfather, see below). 

     5. Solomon Allen, son of Isaac Allen and Abigail Burnham, born in the Chebacco Parish after 1763, no further information.  He is my 5th great uncle, the brother to Joseph Allen (1776 - 1861) my 5th great grandfather. 

     6. Solomon Allen (I don’t know his parents), married on 5 April 1794 in West Gloucester to Mary Allen, daughter of William Allen and Tabitha Bray, born 4 September 1775 in Gloucester, died 15 October 1849 in Gloucester.  Mary is my 1st cousin, 6 generations removed.  

Which Solomon Allen is the Solomon Allen III, shipmaster of Gloucester? 

More information for the truly curious:

From the UnMuseum website

Books about this sea monster:
The Great New England Sea Serpent: An Account of Unknown Creatures Sighted by Many Respectable Persons between 1638 and Present Day, by J. P. O’Neil, Paraview Special Editions, 2003

Gloucester’s Sea Serpent, by Wayne Soini, History Press, 2010


To cite/link to this blog post: Heather Wilkinson Rojo, "A Halloween Ancestor Story!  The Gloucester Sea Monster", Nutfield Genealogy, posted October 29, 2012, ( accessed [access date]). 


  1. Oh, my, that is a monster of a problem! But a great and interesting post.

  2. It could have been a mola mola a rare sunfish for these waters, but we seen one on July 28, of Grand Manan N.B.

  3. Yep. I've got those Solomon Allens in my line. Well by paternal grandfather's line that turns out not to be my bio line, but I've struggled with that crew for years.